You want to make great BBQ, so you say. Well first you have to know the difference between grilling and BBQn. If so, hopefully this information well serve you well
Click on photo to enlarge!
This 10 pound brisket was cooked for a total of 12 hours with hickory wood and I’m here to tell you neither teeth nor sauce are required to enjoy this tender and flavorful piece of meat.

My first and only recommendation for the backyard smoker or someone who wants to make the best BBQ on the planet is to buy the Weber Smoker Mountain Smoker/Grill Model 721001. I have been doing this long enough to know the difference between a superior smoker and an inferior one. Don’t waste your time or money on one of those $175.00 smokers that you find in places like Home Depot or the like. They are not up to the task and you will most probably never achieve perfection. And if you think that you need a $1,000 or more smoker, think again. The added cost is not necessary unless you are a caterer or need to smoke meat in very cold conditions. But for the majority of us, the Weber is all that you will ever need to produce championship quality BBQ for less than $300 (delivered from Amazon.com) and at the end of the day, this is what is all about.
http://www.amazon.com/Weber-721001-Smokey-Mountain-Cooker/dp/B001I8ZTJ0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1247518263&sr=8-1
Listed below are some “links” to videos that you may find interesting. You will notice in the first one that it is the older Weber Smokey Mountain model 2820 Smoker/Grill without a temp gauge, the larger water bowl and the heat deflector that protects your deck from the high heat. (I use a heat resistant mat under my new version smoker just to be on the safe side)
Both videos are informative from different perspectives. I have to tell ‘ya that once I was trying to put the middle section onto the lower section when the pan full of hot tap water fell through. It was not a catastrophic loss as I was able to get it out without soaking too many of the coals with water. It is amazing just how hot it can be trying to set the bowl into the middle section or try to set both the bowl and middle section onto the hot bottom section. But with a good pair of heat resistant gloves, it is not a problem although the best way would probably be to fill the bowl with a garden hose. The only draw back to this is that it will take a bit longer for the water to heat up and stabilize the overall temp but this takes only a few minutes.
To view these videos links you will have to copy them and place them into your web browser to view. Please do this as the information about the grill and a cooking demonstration by some college folks is both informative and interesting.
http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=weber%20smokey%20mountin%20viedio&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wv#
http://www.strimoo.com/video/16393759/Ribs-Vimeo.html
In the second video there was way too much smoke…too much smoke is not a good thing. Most of it went out of the top vent or around the seams of the lid. This is a result of using wood chips that burn very quickly and spikes your temperature… and this is also not a good thing. Wood chunks don’t do this. Your objective is a consistent and steady stream of smoke that easily exits through the top vent.
Personally, I like to layer the charcoal. One good solid base layer, then some wood, and then another layer of charcoal and then a few chunks of wood on top. Using this method you should never have to pitch in a piece of wood. What you don’t want to do is have a huge amount of wood tar coating your food and that is why a steady stream of smoke vice a big burst makes the difference if you want really good BBQ.
I know that all of this may seem complicated but it is not and is only necessary if you are looking to make championship quality BBQ. Quite frankly, there is no other way and the difference is in technique. Again, the key requirement for great BBQ is a steady temp of about 225 degrees on the temp gauge of your smoker and a nice even consistent stream of smoke. That’s it and don’t forget it!
A digital thermometer is critical to good BBQ. Feed the probe down through the top vent that ALWAYS remains open while you are smoking. Stick the probe in the appropriate section of the meat that you are cooking, close the lid, attach the probe to the thermometer and shade the unit. DO DOT OPEN THE LID TO SEE HOW YOUR BBQ LOOKS…NO MATTER HOW TEMPTING IT MAY BE. Remember, the difference between okay BBQ and great BBQ is a steady temp. Every time you lift the lid you lose the edge!
The only time that you should open the lid is to either put meat in or take it off. For instance, lets say that you are having some very special guests over for supper and you want to make a great beef brisket and some wonderful pork or beef ribs. The brisket will take at least 12 hours for a 10 lb. cut. The ribs will take about 4-5 hours. Place the prepared brisket on the lower rack and stabilize the temp to about 220-250 degrees based on the temp gauge on the lid. Smoke for 7 hours, then with your ribs ready to add, quickly take off the lid, put the ribs onto the top rack and replace the lid.
If you are using a rib rack (and you should) this will take no more than 10 seconds and the rack will allow you to smoke more meat while occupying less space by spacing meats vertically vice horizontally as long as they are not too tall and touch the upper grill or lid. However, your meats will decrease in size as the cooking process progresses so don’t be overly concerned.
As for pork ribs, I hold the minority opinion in that the meat should not be falling off the bone. I like a little bite and a little bit of a chew. Not much mine you, but enough where the meat will stay on the rib as you are holding and eating it. But this is my preference. It’s kinda like Fillet Mignon vs. a rib-eye steak…gum it or chew it. Unfortunately, I think too many people rate great BBQ pork ribs by the fall-off the bone criteria.
Here is another way I do things that differ than most. I like to BBQ my brisket at least the day before eating. I let it rest and cool to room temp and then refrigerate it. The next day, I slice it (across the grain)and warm it in the microwave. It carves easier than when hot and you can be assured that all of the juices will be rendered back into the meat after it has cooled making for a juicier end result. Also, after cooking for 12 hours who wants to entertain.
Let’s be real…after cooking for 12 hours it’s time for bed. Better left for the next day. With that said, make 2 briskets, slice and freeze the other for another day.
As for the ribs, same day smoking and eating is perfect with the Weber Smokey Mountain Smoker and absent the brisket, there will be more room for more ribs. Just slice up your previously smoked brisket, heat it up, smile, and enjoy your day.
Note: Please remember to place room temp meat on your smoker. To prepare the meat just rub on your favorite spice mix, no mopping is EVER required.
If at this point you have any questions as to my choice in selecting the new and improved Weber Mountain model 721001, please refer to the reviews of the older Weber 2820 where there are 249 reviews. Any and all complaints of the 2820 were addressed and incorporated in the newer 721001 model
Additionally, forgot to mention that I once cooked 8 whole chickens; and another time I cooked a 10 lb brisket and 4 chickens on my 721001 Model Weber. But to up the ante, they have a larger model, the 731001 that costs less than $400.00 that would cook enough for a small army!
I hope that you benefit from this article on making great BBQ in the Weber Mountain Cooker/Smoker.
24 June 2011 – I just received an email request for the spice recipe that I used. When I made this brisket I used Jake’s Boss BBQ rub. Since then I have found that Coopers “original” spice rub from Llano, TX is superior on beef. Cooper’s spice rub can be purchased online.